Monday, September 19, 2011

Floyd Mayweather Jr. vs. Manny Pacquiao: Who would win? [Poll]

Floyd Mayweather Jr. and Manny Pacquiao

Floyd Mayweather Jr. vs. Manny Pacquiao: It's the fight everybody wants, but who knows if the planets will ever align just right and we will actually get to see it?

If the main event to end all main events ever happens, who would win, Pacquiao or Mayweather?

Writers from around Tribune Co. will discuss the topic. Check back throughout the day for their opinions.

And we want your opinion too -- weigh in by voting in the poll and leaving a comment.

RELATED:

Photos: Floyd Mayweather Jr.-Victor Ortiz

Bill Dwyre: Jeers for outcome of Mayweather-Ortiz are justified

Manny Pacquiao, Floyd Mayweather Jr. and boxing's age-old issue

Floyd Mayweather Jr. basks in aftermath of knockout of Victor Ortiz

Left photo: Floyd Mayweather Jr. Credit: Isaac Brekken / Associated Press

Right photo: Manny Pacquiao. Credit: Julie Jacobson / Associated Press

Monday Matchup: Giants vs. Rams

Rams (0-1) at Giants (0-1), 8:30 p.m. Eastern, ESPN

Line: Giants by 6

Receiver Hakeem Nicks (knee) returned to practice late last week for the Giants and said that he expected to play Monday night. Defensive lineman Justin Tuck (neck) was also back in practice last week and is expected to play.

Giants fans may no longer recognize the brief updates in the previous paragraph. They are an example of what sports journalists and fans call “good injury news.” Good injury news occurs when a player recovers more quickly than expected, or when his original prognosis was more serious than his actual ailment. Good injury news is relatively common in the N.F.L., but the Giants have not encountered much lately; their last confirmed case involved Jessie Armstead in 1996.

In case Nicks cannot play, the Giants signed the 35-year old receiver Brandon Stokley, who caught a touchdown pass against them in Super Bowl XXXV. The Giants also invited members of the 1986 Super Bowl team to the game to sign autographs, giving Stokley some people close to his age to talk to, and reminding fans that a team with absolutely no wide receivers can achieve great things.

The return to health of Nicks and Tuck, the inspiring presence of some former stars and the relative weakness of the Rams have caused another unfamiliar sensation in Giants fans: optimism. That’s the feeling that the Giants are probably going to win, folks. There is no reason to consult a doctor. Pick: Giants

The aftermath: Floyd Mayweather will always be the media bad boy…with Manny Pacquiao the media darling



Some things are just meant to be. Floyd Mayweather’s successful ring return after a 16-month absence was

shrouded in controversy and outrage here on Saturday night when he was accused

of "blindsiding" opponent Victor Ortiz with two illegal blows in a

widely contentious fourth-round finish. Mayweather will always be the bad boy. Just as he will always be a marketing genius. And just as Manny Pacquiao will remain a media darling. Just the way it is.


As the great Samuel Johnson, an English journalist of the last century, once wrote: the best journalism follows certain credos. His motto ? Research meticulously. Simplify. Exaggerate. For these principles, read Mayweather and Pacquiao. And those aspects will not change until the pair are long gone from the ring.


The final act of this absorbing World Boxing Council welterweight

title fight will fall into the annals of boxing’s most debated

finishes, yet the bizarre denouement merely masked the deficiencies of

work-in-progress Ortiz, and enhanced the sublime skills which Mayweather possesses.


Mayweather was accused of unsportsmanlike behaviour, yet he claimed

rigourously that he had merely acted within his rights, moments after

he had been headbutted viciously by Ortiz. There was the whiff of

retribution in his action.


Victory saw Mayweather win back the world title and extend his

unbeaten career to 42 contests, yet the manner of victory and his

comportment after the fight will divide opinion across the globe.


Mayweather even found himself drawn into a slanging match live on air

in the immediate aftermath of the contest with the veteran interviewer

Larry Merchant, which ended with the broadcaster telling

the fighter he would have whipped his ***, “if I was 50 years younger”.


The denouement was as dramatic as it was decisive: Mayweather, who was

dominating the contest in that final round, having peppered the man

ten years his junior with his right-hand lead, found himself caught on

the ropes by Ortiz.


As Mayweather covered up in defence, ducking and swaying, the two

fighters' heads came close together and Ortiz headbutted his opponent

like a pogo-ing punk rocker. The action was both inexplicable and

shocking. It was also deliberate beyond any doubt.


Mayweather recoiled away in shock, referee Joe Cortez deducted a

point, while Ortiz went to plant a kiss on Mayweather's cheek, hugged

him and apologised.


Cortez then sent Ortiz to a neutral corner. It was a singular sequence

that was about to get even more bizarre.


Cortez indicated that the point had been deducted. The fighters came

together in the middle of the ring. Mayweather held out his hands, to

touch, and Ortiz went to embrace his rival, again apologetic.


As they moved apart, Ortiz did not have his hands up. Mayweather threw

a left hook which wobbled Ortiz, who glanced at Cortez as if seeking

instruction. In that same moment, Mayweather threw a hard straight

right.


Ortiz went down. Cortez counted him out. There was outrage and uproar

from many of the 14,687 witnesses in attendance in the MGM Grand

Garden Arena.


Ortiz claimed: "He blindsided me. I'm not a dirty fighter. I

apologised for the headbutt. I took the break and obeyed exactly what

I was told [by the referee].”


“In a sense he caught me as a payback. I spaced out. I didn’t see the

punches coming. I went blank. I woke up afterwards. I didn’t hear Joe

Cortez say ‘box’.”


However, Cortez explained his decision to count out the 24-year old

American: “Time was ‘in’ again, and the fighter has to have his guard

up. Mayweather did nothing wrong.”


It was a contest in which Mayweather looked dominant, aggressive,

measured and the consummate fighter. He was dominant from the opening

round. Calls for a contest between Mayweather, and his greatest rival,

the Filipino Manny Pacquiao, will again gather momentum, although

Britain's Amir Khan is desperately seeking his moment in the spotlight

against the fighter whose career earnings could reach the $150 million

mark before he retires.


Mayweather said: "In the end, you have to protect yourself at all

times. His trainer accused me of being dirty, and yet he [Ortiz]

headbutted me. What goes around, comes around in this sport. When I'm

in the square circle, I'm in my home."


The debate over the end to this fight will continue, yet the bottom

line here was that Ortiz took his eye off the ball, while Mayweather

kept his eye on the prize, fairly or unfairly. The longer-term

argument is whether Pacquiao – or anyone in this generation including

young pretenders like Khan – have the ring skills to dethrone the

controversial American fighter.



Sunday, September 18, 2011

Rams at Giants: Matchup to Watch

RAMS (0-1) at GIANTS (0-1), Monday at 8:30 p.m. Eastern, ESPN


Giants’ Secondary vs. Sam Bradford

Allowing Rex Grossman to pass for 305 yards in Week 1 didn’t do much to help the mood surrounding the Giants’ makeshift secondary, which was weakened by injuries during the preseason. The Giants say their mistakes are correctable, but Bradford — despite an injured finger — has the arm to hurt the Giants if the uncertainty returns. Look for safeties Antrel Rolle and Kenny Phillips to be more of a force if the Giants are to show improvement.

Number to watch: 75

That was how many rushing yards the Giants totaled in Week 1, with starter Ahmad Bradshaw recording 44 yards on 13 carries and his backup, Brandon Jacobs, getting only 6 touches for 29 yards. The Giants moved away from the running game against the Redskins, but establishing a ground attack is imperative if they are going to have success. This week could be a prime opportunity for the backs to break out: the Rams allowed 236 rushing yards in Week 1.

Quotation of the Week

“I plead the fifth.”
Giants linebacker Mathias Kiwanuka, when asked if the Giants’ defense would target Bradford’s injured finger.

Lexi Thompson, 16, is youngest winner of LPGA Tour event

Lexi Thompson

Lexi Thompson, 16, became the youngest player to win an LPGA Tour event when she captured the victory at the Navistar LPGA Classic in Prattville, Ala., on Sunday.

Thompson, who is from Coral Springs, Fla., eclipsed the mark of Paula Creamer, who was 18 when she won her first event in 2005. Thompson clinched the victory at 17-under-par 271 with a 70 on Sunday and finished five shots ahead of Tiffany Joh.

"This has been my dream, like, my whole life," said Thompson, who has brothers playing on the PGA Tour and in college. "It's the best feeling ever."

Although she admitted to being nervous, Thompson said, "Once I hit the first tee shot I was like, 'OK, I'm good.' "

Thompson, who qualified for her first pro tournament at 12 and turned pro at 15, is in the process of attaining an LPGA Tour card. Her petition for qualifying school was granted this summer, and she won the first stage by 10 strokes in July. There are two more stages to go.

"We haven't really talked about that yet," said her father, Scott Thompson, who caddied for her. "We'll worry about that as it comes, so we'll see."

-- Dan Loumena

Photo: Lexi Thompson with the winner's trophy after her victory in the Navistar LPGA Classic on Sunday. Credit: Lloyd Gallman / Associated Press

Angels hope fast start puts pressure on Rangers

The Angels' game in Baltimore will probably be entering the fourth inning Sunday before the team they're chasing in the American League West, the Texas Rangers, start their contest with the Mariners three time zones away.

So if the Angels get off to a quick start against the Orioles they'll be hoping the Rangers, scoreboard-watching in Seattle, will notice.

"You put some pressure on them," the Angels' Bobby Abreu said. "That just makes them look up, 'Hey we have to win today. If we lose, it’s going to be another game.' For us, it’s good right now that we play [earlier]. If we win you put pressure on those guys."

It hasn't worked so far this weekend with the Angels losing their first two games in Baltimore. They've lost four of their last six overall, falling 4 1/2 games behind the Rangers with 11 games to play.

And desperate times call for desperate measures, which is one reason the Angels are starting right-hander Jered Weaver on three days' rest Sunday. Weaver has pitched on short rest just one other time in his career and it didn't go well with the Rangers reaching him for seven runs in six-plus innings. But by shaking up the rotation, Angel Manager Mike Scioscia can start Weaver three more times while the Angels Big Three of Weaver, Dan Haren and Ervin Santana will combine to pitch seven of the final 11 games.

Scioscia said Sunday he was not considering using Haren and Santana on short rest down the stretch.

The lineups:

Angels

SS -- Erick Aybar

2B -- Howie Kendrick

DH -- Bobby Abreu

RF -- Torii Hunter

1B -- Mark Trumbo

3B -- Alberto Callaspo

LF -- Vernon Wells

CF -- Peter Bourjos

C -- Jeff Mathis

P -- Jered Weaver

Baltimore Orioles

CF -- Matt Angle

SS -- J.J. Hardy

RF -- Nick Markakis

DH -- Vladimir Guerrero

1B -- Chris Davis

3B -- Josh Bell

2B -- Robert Andino

LF -- Kyle Hudson

C -- Craig Tatum

P -- Alfredo Simon

-- Kevin Baxter in Baltimore

Floyd Mayweather Jr., Victor Ortiz debate knockout ending

Boxing2_600

Not that anyone was expecting an apology, but Floyd Mayweather Jr. didn’t give one for the way he ended his world welterweight title victory over Victor Ortiz on Saturday night at the MGM Grand Garden Arena.

“What goes around, comes around,” Mayweather Jr. said in celebration of his fourth-round knockout. “You wanted a knockout, that’s what I gave you.”

Questions of sportsmanship, boxing ground rules and fairness were raised from the conclusion of the bout, which was set up by Ortiz delivering a vicious head butt to Mayweather’s mouth in the closing seconds of the fourth.

Referee Joe Cortez stopped the action, and quickly deducted a point from Ortiz, who had forced a close round after losing the first three on two of three judges’ scorecards.

Ortiz actually kissed Mayweather on the cheek after the cheap shot, and Mayweather fumed as he tasted blood from cuts inside his mouth.

Action had yet to resume, and Ortiz was still seeking forgiveness, asking for a hug when Mayweather had immediate revenge on his mind.

“You could see the anger on your face, like all the experience of your long career was being used to get this guy back,” a reporter said to Mayweather.

“Thank you,” Mayweather said, placing his hand on the questioner’s arm. “It was time to fight. What was he going to do? Hug me again? This guy who said I was a dirty fighter?”

So Mayweather watched Cortez closely, and even though Cortez’s gaze was directed elsewhere, Mayweather said boxing ethics are that once the combatants touch gloves, “It’s fight time. It’s open season.”

Did Ortiz hear “Box!” from Cortez? He said no.

Comment

Comment